CO129-260 - Governor Sir Robinson Acting Governor O-Brien - 1893 [9-12] — Page 145

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

Document pass on to the Secretary of State without further remarks by myself.

2. My reasons for asking permission to remain silent are these. On 14 July last I earnestly begged to be relieved of all connection with Victoria College on account of the hostile attitude assumed by the Head Master. But I was ordered to proceed with the examination of the College on the basis of the scheme to which the Head Master had given his cordial approval. I did so. I examined carefully into the condition of the College in strict accordance with that scheme and reported the results honestly, therefore without fear or favour, and as before God and my conscience. My position and attitude was that of an impartial examiner.

I have now read the Head Master's strictures on my report, but see no reason to modify my views. If I were to enter upon any discussion of the Head Master's criticisms of my report, I would have to relinquish the attitude of an independent examiner and to descend into the arena of polemics. I do not apprehend my instructions to imply that, nor do I believe it would serve any useful purpose. I am quite content to abide by any decision the Government may come to in the matter, feeling sure that, even if my report should fail to convince the Government of the truths embodied in it, the course of events will in due time bring a full justification of my assertion that both the organization and methods of the College require a radical reform before it can possibly be what it ought to be, viz. the model...

144

Edit History

2026-05-27 04:47:24 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
Document pass on to the Secretary of State without further remarks by myself. 2. My reasons for asking permission to remain silent are these. On 14 July last I earnestly begged to be relieved of all connection with Victoria College on account of the hostile attitude assumed by the Head Master. But I was ordered to proceed with the examination of the College on the basis of the scheme to which the Head Master had given his cordial approval. I did so. I examined carefully into the condition of the College in strict accordance with that scheme and reported the results honestly, therefore without fear or favour, and as before God and my conscience. My position and attitude was that of an impartial examiner. I have now read the Head Master's strictures on my report, but see no reason to modify my views. If I were to enter upon any discussion of the Head Master's criticisms of my report, I would have to relinquish the attitude of an independent examiner and to descend into the arena of polemics. I do not apprehend my instructions to imply that, nor do I believe it would serve any useful purpose. I am quite content to abide by any decision the Government may come to in the matter, feeling sure that, even if my report should fail to convince the Government of the truths embodied in it, the course of events will in due time bring a full justification of my assertion that both the organization and methods of the College require a radical reform before it can possibly be what it ought to be, viz. the model... 144
Baseline (Original)
? socument pass on to the Secretary of State without further remarks by my. i self. 2. My rea reasaro · for asking per- mission to rear air silent are these. On 14 July last I earnestly begged to be relieved of all connection with Victoria College hostile attitude assumed by ELL the ccount of by the Head Master. But I was ordered to proceed with the examination of the College on the basis of the scheme to which the Head Master had given his cordial. examined the approval. carefully I did so. II into the condi. sion of with that scheme and reported the as before God and College in strict accordance results hor honestly therefore without year or favour of my position and attitude man. But was that of Get impartial examiner. I have now read the Head Master's sprichures trichures ou reason to m 144 If Devere my report, but see no modify my views. If to enter upon any discussion of the Head Master's criticisms of my report, I would have to relinquish the atti- tude of arn independent examiner and to descend into the arena. of polemics. I do not apprehend my instructions to imply that, nor dod believe it would serve purpose. I am by any decis any public quite content to abide decision the Government may come to in the matter, feeling 1 sure that, even if my report should fail to convince the Governm ment of the truths embodied in it, the course of events will in due time bring a full. justification of my assertion that both the organization and methods the College require of reform before it can come what it a radical ought pos bly be_ to be viz. the model
2026-05-27 04:47:24 · Baseline
View content

?

socument pass

on to the Secretary of

State without further remarks by my.

i

self.

2.

My rea

reasaro

· for asking per-

mission to rear air silent are these.

On 14 July last I earnestly begged to be relieved of all connection with Victoria College hostile attitude assumed by

ELL

the

ccount of

by the

Head Master. But I was ordered to

proceed with the examination of the College

on the basis of the scheme

to which the Head Master had given

his cordial.

examined

the

approval.

carefully

I did so. II

into the condi.

sion of with that scheme and reported the as before God and

College in strict accordance

results hor

honestly

therefore without year or

favour of

my position and attitude

man. But

was that of

Get

impartial examiner.

I have now read the Head Master's

sprichures

trichures ou

reason

to m

144

If Devere

my report, but see no modify my

views. If to enter upon any

discussion of the

Head Master's criticisms of my report,

I would have to relinquish the atti- tude of

arn

independent examiner

and to descend into the arena.

of

polemics. I do not apprehend my instructions to imply that, nor dod

believe it would serve

purpose. I am

by any decis

any public

quite content to abide

decision the Government may

come to in the matter, feeling

1

sure

that, even if my report should fail to convince the Governm

ment of the truths embodied in it, the course of events will in due time bring

a full.

justification of my assertion that

both the organization and methods

the

College require

of

reform before it can

come what it

a radical

ought

pos bly be_ to be viz. the

model

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.